A Festival of Analgesics

    Aspirin can be wonderful stuff, but it isn't perfect. Sometimes it may be better to use a different pain reliever. Since aspirin was introduced in 1897, a number of other over-the-counter analgesics have become available. We're going to take a look at some of them.
      Menu

      Acetaminophen
      Ibuprofen
      Naproxen Sodium and Ketoprofen
      COX-2 Inhibitors

    Acetaminophen

    Click to see a acetaminophen molecule in 
3-D!
      acetaminophen
    Long ago there was a pain reliever called
    phenacetin. In 1889, eight years before Felix Hoffmann synthesized aspirin, another German scientist, Karl Morner, discovered that the body broke phenacetin down into another compound, acetaminophen. Acetaminophen was actually responsible for reducing pain and fever. No one paid much attention to this discovery until years later, when people learned that phenacetin was really too dangerous to use as a drug. But a small drug company in Pennsylvania called McNeil Laboratories decided to take a look at acetaminophen. It turned out that acetaminophen had all the pain- and fever-reducing power of phenacetin (of course) but was much safer. Since it didn't cause stomach upset like aspirin could, McNeil first sold acetaminophen in 1955 as a pain and fever reliever for children, calling it Tylenol Children's Elixir. Appropriately for an antipyretic, it was sold in a package that looked like a red fire truck.

    Click for larger picture!
    Acetaminophen products.
      Click for larger picture!
      Early Tylenol® packages.

    Since then it has become a popular adult medication as well, in part because it doesn't cause stomach upset. It doesn't reduce swelling like aspirin, and large overdoses can cause liver damage. Acetaminophen began as a children's medication, and, is still the preferred pain reliever for children due to the connection between Reye's syndrome and aspirin in children with influenza or chicken pox. Acetaminophen is found in Tylenol, and in Bristol-Myers Squibb's Excedrin, which contains both aspirin and acetaminophen.

    As for the small drug company that first sold acetaminophen, McNeil Laboratories grew quite large, thanks to the success of its Tylenol, and eventually became a subsidiary of Johnson & Johnson.

    Ibuprofen

    Click to see a ibuprofen molecule in  3-D!
    ibuprofen
    In the early 1960s scientists figured out that certain
    organic acids, like aspirin, were good at reducing inflammation. The Boots Company, a British drug maker, synthesized over 600 new organic acids looking for anti-inflammatory drugs. A scientist named Stuart Adams made one called ibuprofen that was twice as potent as aspirin as an anti-inflammatory. It was first sold in the United Kingdom as an arthritis treatment and later in the United States as the prescription drug Motrin.
    Click for larger picture!
    Ibuprofen products.

    Since 1984 it has been available over-the-counter under names like Advil, Motrin IB, and Nuprin. Ibuprofen can cause stomach upset (though not as often as aspirin), but on the positive side, regular use has been linked to a reduced risk of Alzheimer's disease, though the evidence is not yet conclusive. It is thought that ibuprofen works by inhibiting the body's ability to make prostaglandins, much like aspirin does.

    Naproxen Sodium and Ketoprofen

    Naproxen sodium and ketoprofen are powerful pain relievers that became available over-the-counter in the mid-1990s. Naproxen sodium is sold by Bayer under the name Aleve and ketoprofen is sold by American Home Products under the name Orudis KT. Both appear to work by inhibiting prostaglandins, like aspirin does. But also like aspirin, they can cause stomach upset and other gastrointestinal problems. Take a look at the molecular structures of these drugs and you'll see they are chemically similar to ibuprofen.

    Click to see a naproxen sodium molecule in 
3-D!
    naproxen sodium
      Click for larger picture!
        Naproxen sodium and ketoprofen
        products.
      Click to see a ketoprofen molecule in 
3-D!
      ketoprofen

    COX-2 Inhibitors

    Severe arthritis patients are often treated with ibuprofen, naproxen sodium, or ketoprofen. While these drugs usually don't cause stomach problems at the doses found in medicines sold over-the-counter, at the higher doses used in prescription drugs gastrointestinal bleeding and ulcers may occur.

    These drugs, and aspirin, work by inhibiting cyclooxygenases. One cyclooxygenase, called COX-2, helps make the prostaglandins that help us feel pain. But another, COX-1, helps protect the inside of your stomach. Recently scientists have been investigating COX-2-inhibiting drugs that leave COX-1 alone. These are the so-called superaspirins, and they tend to be more powerful and cause less stomach and intestinal trouble than other analgesics.

    Click to see the celecoxib molecule in 3-D!
    celecoxib
      Click to see the rofecoxib molecule in 3-D!
      rofecoxib

    Until recently there were two COX-2 inhibitors on the market, celecoxib and rofecoxib. Celecoxib is a product of the companies Searle and Pfizer and is sold under the name Celebrex®. Rofecoxib was made by Merck & Co. and sold as Vioxx®. Both reduce the activity of COX-2 without inhibiting COX-1 very much. Of course, they are expensive, not the sort of thing you'd take for everyday headaches, but they could be just the thing for arthritis sufferers whose stomachs can't handle other analgesics.

    The new superaspirins weren't without their drawbacks. Unlike aspirin, which reduces the ability of blood to clot and therefore reduces the risk of heart attack and stroke, COX-2 inhibitors actually increase the ability of blood to clot. This led to fears that they could lead to an increased risk of heart attack and stroke in some patients. In fact, Merck took rofecoxib off the market in 2004 after it was linked to increased risk of heart disease. Today, only celcoxib is still used.

    Both celecoxib and rofecoxib were designed specifically to be COX-2 inhibitors. The scientists who created them designed their molecular structures using what was known about how different molecules interact with the body. In this sense, they are designing drugs much in the way that Felix Hoffmann and Arthur Eichengrün did over one hundred years ago.

    Now that you've learned all about the different analgesics out there, it might be a good time for an activity in which you get to decide which one is best for a given patient. This activity is called Compare the Painkillers.

      Next: Salsa Analgesica

    Back to:

    Aspirin Adventures Home | Site Map | Pharmaceutical Achievers Home


    Bibliography

      Mann, Charles C., and Plummer, Mark L. The Atlantic Monthly, 1988, 262(4), 39.

      McGrath, Kimberly, ed. World of Invention, 2nd ed. Detroit: Gale Research, 1999.

    Additional reading

      Underwood, Anne. "Life After Vioxx," Newsweek, January 31, 2005, p. 40.

    Image credit

      Early Tylenol® packages: Courtesy McNeil Consumer Health Care. Photo by Will Brown.


    Copyright ©2001 The Chemical Heritage Foundation