A Festival of Analgesics
Aspirin can be wonderful stuff, but it isn't perfect. Sometimes it may be better to use a
different pain reliever. Since aspirin was introduced in 1897, a number of other
over-the-counter
analgesics
have become available. We're going to take a look at some of
them.
![]() acetaminophen |
![]() Acetaminophen products. |
Since then it has become a popular adult medication as well, in part because it doesn't cause stomach upset. It doesn't reduce swelling like aspirin, and large overdoses can cause liver damage. Acetaminophen began as a children's medication, and, is still the preferred pain reliever for children due to the connection between Reye's syndrome and aspirin in children with influenza or chicken pox. Acetaminophen is found in Tylenol, and in Bristol-Myers Squibb's Excedrin, which contains both aspirin and acetaminophen.
As for the small drug company that first sold acetaminophen, McNeil Laboratories grew quite
large, thanks to the success of its Tylenol, and eventually became a subsidiary of Johnson &
Johnson.
Ibuprofen
![]() ibuprofen |
![]() Ibuprofen products. |
Since 1984 it has been available
over-the-counter under names like Advil, Motrin IB, and Nuprin. Ibuprofen can cause stomach
upset (though not as often as aspirin), but on the positive side, regular use has been linked
to a reduced risk of Alzheimer's disease, though the evidence is not yet conclusive. It is
thought that ibuprofen works by inhibiting the body's ability to make
prostaglandins,
much like aspirin does.
Naproxen Sodium and Ketoprofen
Naproxen sodium and ketoprofen are powerful pain relievers that became available
over-the-counter in the mid-1990s. Naproxen sodium is sold by Bayer under the name Aleve and
ketoprofen is sold by American Home Products under the name Orudis KT. Both appear to work
by inhibiting prostaglandins, like aspirin does. But also like aspirin, they can cause
stomach upset and other gastrointestinal problems. Take a look at the
molecular
structures of these drugs and you'll see they are chemically similar to ibuprofen.
COX-2 Inhibitors
Severe arthritis patients are often
treated with ibuprofen, naproxen sodium, or ketoprofen. While these drugs usually don't cause
stomach problems at the doses found in medicines sold over-the-counter, at the higher
doses used in prescription drugs gastrointestinal bleeding and ulcers may occur.
These drugs, and aspirin, work by inhibiting cyclooxygenases. One cyclooxygenase, called
COX-2, helps make the prostaglandins that help us feel pain. But another, COX-1, helps protect
the inside of your stomach. Recently scientists have been investigating COX-2-inhibiting drugs
that leave COX-1 alone. These are the so-called superaspirins, and they tend to be more powerful
and cause less stomach and intestinal trouble than other analgesics.
The new superaspirins weren't without their drawbacks. Unlike aspirin, which reduces the ability
of blood to clot and therefore reduces the risk of heart attack and stroke, COX-2 inhibitors
actually increase the ability of blood to clot. This led to fears that they could lead to an
increased risk of heart attack and stroke in some patients. In fact, Merck took rofecoxib off the market in 2004 after it
was linked to increased risk of heart disease. Today, only celcoxib is still used.
Both celecoxib and rofecoxib were designed specifically to be COX-2 inhibitors. The scientists
who created them designed their molecular structures using what was known about how different
molecules interact with the body. In this sense, they are designing drugs much in the way that
Felix Hoffmann and Arthur Eichengrün did over one hundred years ago.
Now that you've learned all about the different analgesics out there, it might be a good time
for an activity in which you get to decide which one is best for a given patient. This
activity is called Compare the Painkillers.
Aspirin Adventures Home |
Site Map |
Pharmaceutical Achievers Home
McGrath, Kimberly, ed. World of Invention, 2nd ed. Detroit: Gale Research, 1999.
Additional reading
Image credit

naproxen sodium

celecoxib
Next: Salsa Analgesica
Bibliography
Mann, Charles C., and Plummer, Mark L. The Atlantic Monthly, 1988, 262(4), 39.
Underwood, Anne. "Life After Vioxx," Newsweek, January 31, 2005, p. 40.
Early Tylenol® packages: Courtesy McNeil Consumer Health Care. Photo by Will
Brown.