Antibiotics in Action

    Go to student version

    Biology Activity
    Spallanzani and Pasteur
    Re-creating Their Experiments

    Major Concept

    The historical battle over the concept of spontaneous generation is a good illustration of scientific inquiry and the need for well-designed experiments. It also illustrates the creative use of data to explain, both correctly and incorrectly, a scientific principle.

    Level and Expected Student Background

    This activity is appropriate for all student levels and could be used as an introductory laboratory exercise.

      Menu

      General Safety Guidelines
      Microbiology Safety Guidelines
      Major Chemical Concept
      Level and Expected Student
      Background

      Time
      Safety
      Materials and Apparatus
      Advance Preparation
      Relevant National Science
      Education Standards

      Relevant New Jersey State
      Science Education Standards

    Time

    Setup time for this activity would require a 45-minute class period, assuming that glassware (special tubing) and broth solution are prepared in advance. Subsequent observations and note-taking would require a maximum of 10 minutes each day.

    Safety

    1. Wear safety goggles.

    2. Use caution when handling hot liquids.

      General Safety Guidelines
      Microbiology Safety Guidelines

    Materials and Apparatus

    You will need the following for each team participating in the activity:

    • Erlenmeyer flasks, 250 ml (7)
    • Glass tubing (7-8 mm diameter), 30 cm long (2) for curved tubing, Flasks #6 & #7
    • Glass tubing (7-8 mm diameter), 8-10 cm long for straight tubing, Flask #5
    • Bunsen burner and wing tip for bending glass
    • Rubber stoppers to fit flasks- 3 with one hole, 2 without holes.
    • Bouillon cube; 750-1000 ml beaker
    • Paraffin or sealing wax (clean soup can for melting wax)
    • Autoclave or pressure cooker
    • Hot plate or microwave for heating broth.
    • Filter apparatus – paper, funnel, and funnel holder (largest capacity)
    • Graduated cylinders, 100 ml (2)
    • Microscopes, glass slides, and coverslips if students want to examine samples of the broth that turns cloudy.

    Advance Preparation

    1. Bouillon can be prepared in advance. Dissolve one cube in 500 ml of warm water. When cool, filter to produce a very clear medium. Peptone (8 grams) can be used in place of the bouillon. Filtering would not then be required.

    2. Glass tubing that needs to be bent should be prepared for students. Make sure the ends are fire polished. When inserting the tubes into the stoppers, use some glycerin on the end of the tubing that is to be inserted. Wear protective gloves when inserting the tubing.

    3. Students should NOT operate the autoclave or pressure cooker.

    4. Sealing the flasks could be done after class by some students if class time for the setups is limited.

    Relevant National Science Education Standards

      Unifying Concepts and Processes — The activity is concerned with evidence, models, and explanations and also with change, constancy, and measurement.

      Science as Inquiry — The activity is concerned with the abilities necessary to do scientific inquiry and also with scientific inquiry.

      Physical Science — The activity is concerned with the structure and properties of matter and is also concerned with chemical reactions.

      Life Science — The activity is concerned with the behavior of organisms.

      History and Nature of Science — The activity is concerned with science as a human endeavor and the nature of scienctific knowledge and provides a historical perspective.

    Relevant New Jersey State Science Education Standards

      5.1 The activity involves conducting systematic observations, interpreting and analyzing data, drawing conclusions, and communicating results.
      5.2 The activity deals with the history and people behind the science involved.
      5.5 The activity requires understanding of the basic characteristics of living organisms.
      5.6 The activity investigates the behavior of matter in biological systems.

    Back to:

    Teacher's Guide Directory | Student Directory | Pharmaceutical Achievers Home


    References

    1. Conant, J.B., ed. Harvard Case Histories in Experimental Science. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1957.

    2. Gabriel, M.L. and Fogel S., eds. Great Experiments in Biology. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall, 1955, pp 105-118.

    3. Brock, T.D., ed. Milestones in Microbiology. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall, 1961.


    Copyright ©2002 The Chemical Heritage Foundation